top of page

New Publication: Veterans’ Preference in Federal Reductions in Force

Nov 7
3 min read

Agard Research Associates Inc. is pleased to share a new policy analysis by Alyssa I. Agard, titled Veterans’ Preference in Federal Reductions in Force: An Analysis of the Reduction-in-Force Rule at 91 Fed. Reg. 49,178 (2026), Drawing on the Statute and Its History, the Rulemaking Record, and Federal Workforce Data. The full report is paired with a three-page summary, a complete reference list, and an interactive guide that lets readers rank sample employees under the old and new rules.


medal

What the report asks

On September 2, 2026, a final rule from the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) changed how federal agencies decide who is kept and who is released in a reduction in force (RIF). The report asks three questions. What does the rule do to the retention preference that federal law gives veterans? Whom does it affect? What options remain? It is organized around one distinction: preference as a priority, which settles every comparison between a veteran and a nonveteran before performance is considered, and preference as a weight, which competes with performance on a common scale.


A place in line becomes a set of points

For decades, a preference-eligible veteran whose performance was acceptable ranked ahead of every nonveteran in the same tenure group. Employees are now ranked by a score built from their three most recent performance ratings. Veterans add 5 points if they have a service-connected disability rated 30 percent or more, and 3 points otherwise. A veteran with a 30 percent disability rating who is rated Fully Successful three times scores 14. A nonveteran rated one level higher three times scores 15 and now ranks ahead.


How much the credit is worth depends on how agencies distribute ratings, which OPM now caps. In ARA’s illustrative modeling, a veteran with three Fully Successful ratings outranks roughly 22 to 77 percent of nonveteran competitors with the 3-point credit. With the 5-point credit, the range is 47 to 94 percent.


Who is affected

Veterans held 27.4 percent of executive branch jobs in fiscal year 2024. Layoffs were rare until recently: RIF separations never exceeded 300 in a fiscal year during the preceding decade, but 10,436 employees were separated by RIF between January 20, 2025, and January 2026.


The change is largest for three groups:

  • veterans outside the Department of Defense, which has ranked employees by performance first since 2017

  • long-serving veterans, because length of service is now only a tie-breaker

  • veterans serving probationary periods, who are removed from RIF competition altogether


Both sides, on equal terms

Consistent with ARA’s nonpartisan mandate, the report presents each side’s case with equal care.

  • OPM: the statute grants “a meaningful retention preference, not a categorical right.”

  • Critics, including federal employee unions: the statute requires only acceptable performance. Their reading draws support from the Supreme Court’s 1948 decision in Hilton v. Sullivan and from Congress’s rejection in 1978 of a time limit on retention preference.


The forum may matter as much as the answer. A companion rule sends RIF appeals to OPM rather than the Merit Systems Protection Board and bars court review of OPM’s decisions. The report takes no position on whether the rule is wise or lawful.


Why this matters

Federal employees, veterans, and the people who advise them need a clear account of what the new rule does. By separating what the rule settles from what remains disputed, the report gives them a record they can rely on as agencies begin to apply it.



Comments


Reasearch Organization Registry (ROR) Logo

859 US Highway 130 

Ste 5 PMB 5020 

East Windsor, NJ 08520-2900

© 2026 Agard Research Associates Inc. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. 


© 2026 Agard Research Associates Inc. All written, visual, and digital content on this site is protected by U.S. and international copyright law. Unauthorized reproduction or distribution is prohibited.​​

bottom of page